I imagine it would look something like these. You art buffs might appreciate this post.
Jasper Johns is an American contemporary artist who often used symbols in his work. Symbols like flags, maps, numbers, letters, and in my mind, our beloved DHARMA logo.
These are nowhere near as good or as tactile as his work, of course. The pictures above are digitally created, but a year ago, I actually made a set of two oil pastel asterisk prints on canvas. And now that I think of it, I should have just done DHARMA logos. Oh well. What's done is done.